CO129-156 - Sir MacDonnell - 1872 [1-3] — Page 370

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Loods of the Admiralty to Admiral Sir Thomas Packy, Bart. - which exactly to meet the question alluded to therein was the precedency of the Major General over the Naval Commanding the troops Commander-in-Chief, on the ground that he was Lieutenant Governor of Plymouth. On reference to the Horse Guards His Royal Highness the Commander-in-Chief expressed the opinion that where the Naval Officer and the General Officer of the two Services hold superior relative rank, he would necessarily be entitled to take precedence of the General Officer Commanding the Troops, even though the latter might happen to be Lieutenant Governor of the Garrison; and the point was decided accordingly.

I believe that decision to have been a wise one, because a decision based on other than the obvious and simple grounds of relative seniority would not give equal satisfaction to the services affected.

R G Gordon, Governor

1st March 1872.

Edit History

2026-05-20 15:12:20 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Loods of the Admiralty to Admiral Sir Thomas Packy, Bart. - which exactly to meet the question alluded to therein was the precedency of the Major General over the Naval Commanding the troops Commander-in-Chief, on the ground that he was Lieutenant Governor of Plymouth. On reference to the Horse Guards His Royal Highness the Commander-in-Chief expressed the opinion that where the Naval Officer and the General Officer of the two Services hold superior relative rank, he would necessarily be entitled to take precedence of the General Officer Commanding the Troops, even though the latter might happen to be Lieutenant Governor of the Garrison; and the point was decided accordingly. I believe that decision to have been a wise one, because a decision based on other than the obvious and simple grounds of relative seniority would not give equal satisfaction to the services affected. R G Gordon, Governor 1st March 1872.
Baseline (Original)
loods of the Admiralty to Admiral Sir Thomas Packy, Bart - which exactly to meet the beenna eya. question alluded to therein was precedency of the Major General The the over the Naval Commanding the troops Commander - in Chief, on the ground that he was Lombinant Governor of lymouth. On resmence to the Horer Guarder His Royal Highness the Commander in Chief expressed the opinion that where the Naval under the regulations "Officer may " of the two Services hold superior : relative rank, he would necessarily " be entitled to taste precedence of the General, officer Commanding the Proops, 570 Treeps, even though the latter might happen to be Lieutenant Governor of "the Tertres ; and the point decided accordingly. I believe that decision to have been a wise one, decision based on because other than the A obvious and simple grounds of relative seniority would not give equal satisfaction to the services affected. R Gellerd semell Governa 1et March 1872.
2026-05-20 15:12:20 · Baseline
View content

loods of the Admiralty to Admiral Sir Thomas Packy, Bart - which

exactly to meet the

beenna eya.

question

alluded to therein was

precedency of the Major General

The

the

over the Naval

Commanding the troops Commander - in Chief, on the ground that he was Lombinant Governor of

lymouth. On resmence to the Horer Guarder His Royal Highness the Commander in Chief expressed the opinion that where the Naval

under the regulations

"Officer may " of the two Services hold superior : relative rank, he would necessarily " be entitled to taste precedence of the General, officer Commanding the

Proops,

570

Treeps, even though the latter might happen to be Lieutenant Governor of "the Tertres ; and the point decided accordingly.

I believe that decision to have been a wise one,

decision based on

because

other than the

A

obvious and simple grounds of relative seniority would not give equal satisfaction to the services affected.

R Gellerd semell

Governa

1et March 1872.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.